Will PJM’s Price Caps Stabilize Capacity Market and Benefit Consumers?

January 30, 2025
Will PJM’s Price Caps Stabilize Capacity Market and Benefit Consumers?

The PJM Interconnection, which oversees the electricity grid for 13 Mid-Atlantic and Midwest states along with the District of Columbia, has agreed to implement price caps and floors for its upcoming capacity auctions. This decision comes in response to a complaint filed in December by Pennsylvania Governor Josh Shapiro to the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission (FERC) amid concerns that the high capacity prices were adversely impacting consumers. As per the agreement, PJM will set a price cap of $325/MW-day and a price floor of $175/MW-day for the capacity auctions to be held for the 2026/27 and 2027/28 delivery years. The next auction is scheduled for July.

The drastic rise in prices from PJM’s last capacity auction fueled the decision to introduce the price caps. The previous auction resulted in a dramatic increase in costs for consumers, soaring to $14.7 billion from just $2.2 billion the year before. This sudden hike drew complaints from various quarters, including governors, utility commissions, and consumer advocates. However, this measure also faced opposition from significant stakeholders like Constellation Energy Generation and the PJM Power Providers Group, who argued that the reforms might disrupt market dynamics.

Potential Savings and Approval Process

Governor Shapiro has asserted that the new price caps could lead to consumer savings estimated at $21 billion over the next two years. However, the legitimacy of this negotiated cap and floor still requires the approval of PJM stakeholders and its board. To facilitate this process, a Special Members Committee meeting is slated for February 7, aimed at providing necessary guidance on implementing this new mechanism. If approved, PJM will then proceed to file a Federal Power Act section 205 application with FERC to officially endorse these changes and integrate them into the upcoming capacity auctions.

This move toward capping prices is positioned as a significant step towards managing costs for consumers and adding a layer of predictability to the otherwise volatile capacity market. Governor Shapiro’s initiative thus stands as a balancing act intended to contain prices while accommodating the genuine operational costs of energy providers in the PJM territory. Approval from key stakeholders and subsequent regulatory bodies will be crucial in determining the future course of these reforms, setting a precedent for capacity market management.

Advocacy for Further Reforms

Despite the immediate relief that the price caps might provide, advocacy groups like Evergreen Action remain vocal about the need for further reforms. They highlight that it’s equally imperative for PJM to tackle existing interconnection issues and expedite the integration of renewable energy sources into the grid. Addressing these additional factors can contribute toward not only lowering overall energy costs but also promoting a sustainable energy future.

These advocacy groups argue that simply capping prices won’t be a long-term solution unless the underlying infrastructure issues are resolved. Ensuring the smooth interconnection of renewable energy sources, reducing dependency on more expensive fossil fuels, and managing the demand dynamics are aspects that need immediate attention. By focusing on these, PJM can not only stabilize the market but also ensure a reliable and affordable energy supply that aligns with the growing thrust towards renewable energy.

Implications for Market Stability

The PJM Interconnection, which oversees the electricity grid for 13 Mid-Atlantic and Midwest states plus the District of Columbia, has agreed to set price caps and floors for its upcoming capacity auctions. This decision followed a December complaint filed by Pennsylvania Governor Josh Shapiro to the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission (FERC), expressing concerns that high capacity prices were negatively affecting consumers. Under this agreement, PJM will cap prices at $325/MW-day and set a floor at $175/MW-day for the capacity auctions scheduled for the 2026/27 and 2027/28 delivery years, with the next auction in July.

The surge in prices from PJM’s last capacity auction led to the decision to introduce price caps. The previous auction caused consumer costs to skyrocket to $14.7 billion from just $2.2 billion the prior year. This massive increase led to complaints from governors, utility commissions, and consumer advocates. However, significant stakeholders like Constellation Energy Generation and the PJM Power Providers Group opposed the measure, arguing that such reforms could disrupt market dynamics.

Subscribe to our weekly news digest.

Join now and become a part of our fast-growing community.

Invalid Email Address
Thanks for Subscribing!
We'll be sending you our best soon!
Something went wrong, please try again later