Maximizing Resiliency in Solar Energy: Balancing Costs and Benefits

January 31, 2025

In the evolving landscape of renewable energy, particularly solar energy, asset owners face a significant choice: invest in resilient, hardened assets or opt for standard equipment to keep initial costs lower. This is an important consideration, as resilience in this context refers to an asset’s ability to withstand, adapt to, and recover from extreme weather events or other natural disruptions. These measures include reinforced mounting systems, hail-resistant modules, and advanced monitoring and response systems. While resilient assets may initially seem more expensive, a comprehensive look at the lifecycle of a project reveals they often pay for themselves, offering greater long-term value.

The Growing Threat to Renewable Assets

Intensifying Storms and Expanding Hail Risk

Climate change is leading to an unprecedented rise in extreme weather events, posing severe challenges to renewable energy infrastructure. Hurricanes and tropical storms, with higher wind speeds and increased rainfall, pose significant threats to both onshore and offshore renewable installations. These intensifying storms can damage equipment or even lead to complete operational shutdowns, jeopardizing energy supply chains. In addition, hailstorms are occurring more frequently, with larger and more damaging hailstones affecting regions previously considered low-risk. Such events can cause substantial damage to solar panels, often beyond repair, leading to high maintenance costs and prolonged outages.

These escalating risks threaten not only individual projects but also the overall growth of the renewable energy sector. With an increasing frequency of these severe weather phenomena, the integrity and reliability of energy infrastructure are more critical than ever. According to data, 2023 has already been a record-breaking year with numerous weather and climate-related disasters, each causing significant economic impact. As these trends continue, renewable asset owners must consider the imperative of resilient design to secure their investments and ensure consistent energy production. Failure to do so could result in substantial financial losses and setbacks in the sector’s progress.

Prolonged Droughts, Wildfires, and Increased Uncertainty

Extended dry periods are leading to more frequent and intense wildfires, jeopardizing solar farms and associated transmission infrastructure in vulnerable areas. These wildfires can cause direct damage to solar installations and indirectly disrupt service due to smoke and particulate matter blocking sunlight. Moreover, the heat generated by fires can damage equipment and reduce the efficiency of solar panels, necessitating costly repairs or replacements. Changing rain patterns are also causing unexpected floods, altering traditional flood maps, and increasing uncertainty within the industry. Such unpredictability complicates planning and risk management strategies, making it crucial for asset owners to consider resilient designs that can withstand these variable conditions.

According to NOAA, 2023 witnessed a record-breaking 28 weather and climate disasters in the U.S., each causing more than $1 billion in damages, a trend that is expected to continue. This highlights the urgent need for the renewable energy industry to adapt and ensure continued growth and sustainability through resilient design. By incorporating measures that enhance the durability and adaptability of solar installations, the industry can better withstand these natural disruptions and maintain consistent energy supply. This proactive approach not only protects assets but also bolsters confidence in renewable energy as a reliable source of power, critical for the sector’s long-term success.

The Upfront Cost of Resilience

Enhanced Panel Design and Advanced Tracking Systems

Implementing resilient measures in renewable energy projects, particularly in solar installations, involves several key components. Enhanced panel design, including the use of thicker, tempered glass (3.2 or 4mm versus the standard 2mm), helps withstand hail and other extreme weather events. These panels are specifically engineered to absorb impact and reduce the likelihood of shattering, thus extending the operational life of the installation. Advanced tracking systems with higher stow angles and automated functionalities offer better protection during severe weather. Deployed trackers typically achieve maximum tilt angles of 52 to 60 degrees, with newer innovations allowing even steeper angles to minimize hail loss.

Recent research from the 2024 Solar Risk Assessment indicates that angles up to 75 degrees can reduce the probability of breakage by over 80%. This technological advancement represents a significant leap in the protection and longevity of solar assets. Regular testing of hail stow systems is advised to ensure these preventive measures are effective and responsive to actual weather conditions. While the initial investment in these advanced panels and tracking systems may be higher, the reduced risk of damage and prolonged operational efficiency contribute to a lower cost of ownership over the lifecycle of the project. This holistic view underscores the financial prudence of opting for resilient designs despite the upfront costs.

Robust Mounting Structures and Regular Maintenance

Choosing durable racking with thicker steel and ensuring modules are securely fastened to withstand high winds and other environmental stressors is crucial for the longevity and efficiency of solar installations. These robust mounting structures are designed to hold firm under extreme conditions, thus preventing dislodgment or damage that could lead to costly repairs and extended downtimes. Regular operations and maintenance tasks, such as torque audits, connector inspections, and spare parts collection, further bolster the resilience of the system. Proactive maintenance ensures that even minor issues are addressed before they become significant problems, maintaining the system’s integrity and efficiency.

While specific costs can vary based on project size and location, research indicates that implementing these resilient measures can increase initial project costs by approximately 10% to 15% compared to standard designs. Despite this, the enhanced longevity and reduced risk of weather-related damage justify the additional investment. For renewable energy projects, particularly solar installations, incorporating resilient designs is not just an option but a necessity. This approach ensures that the systems remain productive and reliable even under adverse conditions, safeguarding both the assets and the financial investment of the stakeholders involved.

Case Study: The Numbers Behind Resiliency

Financial Impact of Resilient Design

To illustrate the financial impact of resilient design, a real-world example can be drawn from a model for a 100-MW solar project situated in a high hail-risk region. The concept of Average Annual Loss (AAL) plays a crucial role in understanding this impact. AAL represents the mean annual loss over the long term, taking into account the probability and severity of various loss events. This is calculated using natural catastrophe models built on historical weather and loss data, providing a comprehensive risk assessment. For a standard design featuring 2mm untempered glass without hail stow precautions, the net loss AAL comes to $1,062,720, with a 30-year aggregate AAL outlook reaching $31,881,600.

These figures highlight the substantial financial risk associated with non-resilient designs, especially in regions prone to severe weather events. Conversely, for a resilient design incorporating 3.2mm tempered glass panels and a robust hail stow protocol with a 52-degree tilt, the net loss AAL drops significantly to $307,790. This represents a 30-year aggregate AAL outlook of $9,233,700. These numbers underscore the effectiveness of resilient design in mitigating financial losses due to extreme weather, illustrating a clear economic benefit over the lifespan of the project. The initial investment in resilient measures, though higher, proves to be cost-effective in the long term.

Benefits of Resilient Design

Implementing resilient design measures results in a $754,930 reduction in average annual loss (AAL) and a $22,647,900 reduction in the 30-year AAL outlook. This massive reduction underscores the financial prudence of investing in resilience. Assuming the resilient design costs 15% more than the standard design, the additional upfront investment amounts to $15,000,000. However, the savings over 30 years, estimated at $22,647,900, far outweigh this initial cost. This results in a net benefit of $7,647,900 over the 30-year outlook. These figures demonstrate that resilient designs are not only financially viable but also crucial for protecting assets in the long term.

As severe weather events become more frequent, non-resilient sites will face increased deductibles, higher premiums, and will ultimately bear a larger portion of losses themselves. Insurers have become increasingly discerning about sites that do not adequately address their geographic risks, often declining to quote entirely on projects lacking adequate resilience measures. In some cases, sites may become completely uninsurable. Moreover, the renewable energy industry’s reputation and growth depend on reliable power generation. Projects frequently offline due to weather damage not only lose revenue but also undermine confidence in clean energy as a dependable power source. Resilient design creates a virtuous cycle of reduced losses, lower premiums, better insurability, and a more stable renewable energy sector.

The Industry Imperative

Insurance and Financial Stability

As severe weather events become more frequent, solar energy sites that lack resilient designs will increasingly face higher insurance premiums and deductibles. Insurers are becoming more discerning about the geographic risks associated with renewable energy assets. Projects that do not incorporate adequate resilience measures are often deemed too risky to insure, leading to a complete lack of coverage or exorbitant costs. This makes resilient designs not only a protective measure but also a financially strategic one. Being unable to secure insurance or facing prohibitive costs can significantly jeopardize the financial viability of solar projects.

Furthermore, the renewable energy industry’s reputation hinges on reliable power generation. Projects that are frequently offline due to weather damage not only lose direct revenue but also undermine investor and public confidence in renewable energy as a dependable power source. This results in a double-edged sword: financial losses due to downtime and weakened market credibility. By prioritizing resilient design, the renewable energy sector can foster a cycle of reduced losses, lower insurance premiums, and better overall project insurability. This stability is crucial for long-term growth and securing the future of solar energy investments.

Ensuring Long-term Growth

In the rapidly advancing field of renewable energy, particularly solar energy, asset owners are confronted with a critical decision: should they invest in resilient, durable assets or go for standard equipment to keep initial costs down? This decision is pivotal because resilience in this context refers to an asset’s capacity to endure, adjust to, and bounce back from severe weather conditions or other natural disturbances. This includes features like fortified mounting systems, hail-resistant solar panels, and sophisticated monitoring and response mechanisms. While these resilient assets may initially appear to be more costly, a thorough examination of a project’s lifecycle often reveals that they pay for themselves over time, offering substantial long-term benefits. Costly upfront, these assets provide greater reliability and lower maintenance costs, ensuring they remain operational under adverse conditions. Investing in them is not just about immediate savings but about securing consistent energy production and durability over many years.

Subscribe to our weekly news digest.

Join now and become a part of our fast-growing community.

Invalid Email Address
Thanks for Subscribing!
We'll be sending you our best soon!
Something went wrong, please try again later